My MLB Players Hall of Fame Eligibilities

Earlier I listed the 181 players that have over 750 points and added 19 more to get 200 total players. Since then I did more research because someone wrote about Kevin Brown using steroids. I did some research and decided he deserved a 10 percent penalty. He went from the 36th greatest pitching career to the 52nd greatest pitching career. Still darn good, but he isn’t in that 750 area any more. Now I have 199 players in my hall of fame. Since I haven’t built it, finalized it or wrote all the player profiles I can do stuff like this.

Basically, since this is my hall of fame, I making up the rules as I go along and I just came up with a new one. Bill James talked about having layers in the hall of fame voting so players on the border don’t get eliminate from the consideration of being elected so soon. Now there is a rule that players who don’t get 5 percent of the votes are taken off the ballot the next year. Seemed sensible at the time, but now there are a lot of darn good players being eliminated after being on the ballot one year.

Since I let in 199 players at once I didn’t feel I should worry about that. However, I looked at my list of 1,000 players and noticed something. There were close to 400 players who had 600 points or more. That is about 2 percent of all the players who have played MLB. I thought those should be the players who are eligible to be put into my hall of fame. It turns out there are 406 players with 600 more points. Some I give them a couple of bonus points to put them over the limit. That means 2.04 percent of the players in MLB history are eligible for my hall of fame.

Let us go by position. We can start at catcher. There are 31 catchers with 600 or more points. Some of the catchers who made the list are Ernie Lombardi who is already in the real hall of fame. If you want the slowest man in baseball history who can hit the ball hard you can campaign for him. Next is Russell Martin who is famous for framing pitches and very good overall on defense. He has a lot of supporters for the hall of fame. Then there is Sherm Lollar who just got over the line. Here is the list of the next nine catchers:

32 Buck Ewing
33 Bob Boone
34 Tim McCarver
35 Tom Haller
36 Del Crandall
37 A.J. Pierzynski
38 Rick Ferrell
39 Mickey Tettleton
40 Benito Santiago


I don’t think I will miss any of these for the hall of fame. Buck Ewing was famous in the 19th Century and he was a catcher. However, he wasn’t even a catcher for half his games. Tim McCarver is famous, but more as an announcer. I think he was an underrated player, but not a hall of famer. Rick Ferrell is in the hall of fame. I think he is in the hall of fame because he caught 4 knuckleballers one year. He was better than I thought, but I really don’t see him as a hall of famer.


First Base

There are 43 first basemen who have 600 or more points. The bottom two are Jake Beckley, who was never great but was consistently very good and Gil Hodges. I helped Gil with an extra point to get to 600. I thought players who were that close should be considered, as I know my formula certainly isn’t that accurate.

44 Ed Konetchy 597.74
45 Paul Goldschmidt 577.55
46 Prince Fielder 571.05
47 Cecil Cooper 568.85
48 Jim Bottomley 563.59
49 Ron Fairly 562.7
50 Freddie Freeman 562.45
51 Dolph Camilli 559.49
52 Frank Chance 558.93


I don’t know much about Ed Konetchy so I am not going to push them. Paul Goldschmidt and Freddie Freeman are still playing. These totals are thru 2019 so they actually have more points. Jim Bottomley is in the hall of fame, but I would put a lot of first basemen ahead of him, so I don’t really see him as a hall of famer. Dolph Camilli has always been a favorite of mine, but tough luck. Frank Chance had a short career which hurts him with my formula. I think he was elected more for his leadership as a player and manager, so I’m fine with him being in as a manager.

Second Base

There are 29 2nd basemen with 600 or more points. Dustin Pedroia just made it over the line. Here is the next group:


30 Buddy Myer
31 Ben Zobrist
32 Jim Gilliam
33 Jose Altuve
34 Bid McPhee
35 Dick McAuliffe
36 Davy Lopes
37 Del Pratt
38 Ray Durham
39 Cupid Childs


Ben Zobrist is just short and didn’t play last year. I don’t see him as a hall of famer now. Jose Altuve didn’t have a good season, and I don’t think he has hall of fame qualities yet. A half way decent season would get him over 600.


Third Base

Like second base 3rd base has 29 players at 600 or more points. Pie Traynor made it with a push from me. He was close and famous enough to get over the line. Here is the next group:

30 Aramis Ramirez
31 Larry Gardner
32 Tim Wallach
33 Josh Donaldson
34 Bil Madlock
35 Matt Williams
36 Carney Lanford
37 Al Rosen
38 Lave Cross
39 Gary Gaetti
40 George Kell


Ramirez was good solid player for a long time, but I don’t consider hem to be close to a hall of famer. Al Rosen started later. He was 26 when he became a starter. He had a super season and was an all-star type player a few other years, but retired at 32. It just wasn’t enough. George Kell is in the Hall of Fame and I never figured out why.


There are 37 shortstops at 600 or above. That is a lot. Nomar Garciaparra, a great hitting shortstop and Joe Tinker a great fielding shortstop made it. Here are the leader who didn’t:

38 Jack Glasscock
39 Dick Groat
40 Al Dark
41 Monte (John) Ward
42 Herman Long
43 Jay Bell
44 Dick Bartell
45 Rico Petrocelli


In a word “No”.

Left Field

There are 40 left fielders on the list, which is too many.

41 Kirk Gibson
42 Jim O’ Rourke
43 Albert Belle
44 Greg Luzinski
45 Harry Stovey
46 Moises Alou
47 Gary Matthews
48 Dusty Baker
49 Del Ennis
50 Don Baylor
51 Alfonso Soriano


It is an easy no on this group.

Center Field

There are 38 center fielders on the list. Again, a lot.

39 Dom DiMaggio
40 Hugh Duffy
41 Steve Finley
42 Andy Van Syke
43 Tori Hunter
44 Roy Thomas
45 Hack Wilson
46 Mike Cameron
47 Ellis Burks
48 Willie Wilson
49 Cy Seymour
50 Clyde Milan
51 Earle Combs


Center Field has some guys on the list who are surprising below 600. Dom DiMaggio is often discussed as a hall of famer. His career was shortened by WWII. I did give points for WWII but I was conservative with that. DiMaggio was underrated as he had a good on base percentage and hit just under .300. He did score a lot of runs but had great players coming up behind him. He was over 5 WAR only once despite being a solid, but not great fielder. I don’t see him as a hall of famer. Hugh Duffy is probably in the hall of fame as he hit .440 one year. However, there isn’t really anything that stands out in his career.

Hack Wilson is another hall of famer. He had 5 all-star seasons according to WAR ending with his best season 1930. He has the single season RBI record and that is probably why he is in the hall of fame. However, I don’t think he was good long enough for how good he was. So I have no problem that he isn’t eligible.

Earle Combs is also a hall of famer. Like DiMaggio he was smart in picking teammates hitting behind him. He was never a great player and didn’t play that long. If there arguably 50 ahead of you at your position (besides pitcher) ahead of you then you more than likely not a hall of famer.

Right Field

There are 39 right fielders with 600 or more points. Here is the next group:

40 Felipe Alou
41 Jose Bautista
42 Roger Maris
43 Chuck Klein
44 Tommy Henrich
45 Johnny Callison


A lot of people argue Roger Maris should be in the hall due to his 61 homeruns. However, I think his career as a whole doesn’t make it.

Starting Pitcher

There are 105 starting pitchers with 600 or more points. That is a good amount. Ron Guidry and Bartolo Colon didn’t make it by much. In fact, Colon I pushed over. These are the 10 who didn’t quite make it:

106 Waite Hoyt
107 Mark Langston
108 Dutch Leonard II
109 George Uhle
110 Sam McDowell
111 Tony Mullane
112 Dolf Luque
113 Jimmy Key
114 Kenny Rogers
115 Babe Adams


Waite Hoyt is in the hall of fame. Again, in part because he picked good teammates. He won 20 twice in an era when pitchers were winning a lot more. I don’t see him as a hall of famer. Also when you arguably not in the top 100 starters that hurts.

Sam McDowell was a great pitcher for a while. He was better than his win – loss record. He should have won the Cy Young Award in 1970. However, he has only 41 WAR in his career.

I always liked Babe Adams but he wasn’t a hall of famer.


Relief Pitchers

Only 15 relief pitchers over 600, which is OK as they don’t pitch a lot of innings. Here are the next 7:

16 Lindy McDaniel
17 Jonathan Papelton
18 Mike Marshall
19 Doug Jones
20 Kent Tekulve
21 Tom Henke
22 Robb Nen

All seven had great seasons, but I wouldn’t push any for the hall of fame.



Leave a Reply