| 161 | Kid Nichols | 776 | P 36 |
| 162 | Keith Hernandez | 775.3 | 1B 21 |
| 163 | Ed Delahanty | 775 | LF 16 |
| 164 | Graig Nettles | 774.3 | 3B 11 |
| 165 | Roy Halladay | 774 | P 37 |
| 166 | Chase Utley | 773 | 2B 15 |
| 167 | Goose Goslin | 771.3 | LF 17 |
| 168 | Carl Hubbell | 771 | P 38 |
| 169 | Don Drysdale | 770.4 | P 39 |
| 170 | Sherry Magee | 770 | LF 18 |
Kid Nichols suffered the most from my 19th Century penalties, but he still made my hall of fame as well as the regular hall of fame. It is nice to see Graig Nettles make my hall of fame. Chase Utley had an interesting career. He was a guy who started his career who could do everything well. I want to see how well he was able to hold on to those skills after going to the Dodgers. I thought Hubbell would be higher, but he had a short career.
