Players 161 – 170 Using Second Rating System

bearbyzaolcom May 17, 2022 Leave a comment

Yet another group of 10:

161	Buster Posey	C 16	Kid Nichols	P 36
162	Lou Boudreau	SS 16	Keith Hernandez	1B 21
163	Robinson Cano	2B 15	Ed Delahanty	LF 16
164	Jesse Burkett	LF 16	Graig Nettles	3B 11
165	Mark McGwire	1B 19	Roy Halladay	P 37
166	Fred McGriff	1B 20	Chase Utley	2B 15
167	Andre Dawson	RF 20	Goose Goslin	LF 17
168	Tommy John	P 40	Carl Hubbell	P 38
169	Dan Brouthers	1B 21	Don Drysdale	P 39
170	Don Drysdale	P 41	Sherry Magee	LF 18

Buster Posey as I mentioned before moved up to the Hall of Fame based on playing last year. My next article will be about him. I already wrote about him, but Lou Boudreau moved up into the hall of fame overcoming his short career, so the new ratings helped. He stayed in the same position at shortstop but moved up the overall list to qualify for the hall of fame.

I think the steroid penalty effective players they (Robinson Cano and Mark McGwire) more in the reranking and they went down. I have no problem with the ranking of these two. Jesse Burkett went down and that is more accurate evaluation of him.

McGriff stayed the same at first base but was passed Votto and Hernandez. Votto passed him because he is still playing so it is like McGriff went up slightly. He is now ahead of all the 19^th Century 1^st basemen, and I defiantly agree with that. Speaking of 19^th Century 1^st basemen, Dan Brouthers passed his two contemporizes. He is one of the few 19^th century players who moved up.

Andre Dawson and Tommy John both had very long career and as a consequence moved down. Don Drysdale moved down slightly.

As stated in early articles Kid Nichols, Keith Hernandez, Goose Goslin and Carl Hubbell both moved way up. Ed Delahanty moved down slightly.

Graig Nettles and Chase Utley moved up slightly and Roy Halladay moved up a fair amount. Sherry McGee no longer made the Hall of Fame automatic minimum. However, he will stay in my Hall of Fame. Left field as less automatic qualifiers which is good.